Letters For Palestine
A Rely to Dane Girauds Misrepresentations and Litany of Lies - Full Version
Late 2020 - update
As usual, I have run in's with our Israel Apartheid and Colonisation Lobbyists from time to time.
The latest one was with Rob Berg - President of the Zionist Federation of NZ. Just before the Very Successful celebration of the United Nations day of Solidarity with the Palestinian people here in Auckland New Zealand. More than 200 people attended this event.
Berg was so incensed that he had to use one of the most vile accusations one can use against a male. A False Smear of Pedophilia.
As usual, I have run in's with our Israel Apartheid and Colonisation Lobbyists from time to time.
The latest one was with Rob Berg - President of the Zionist Federation of NZ. Just before the Very Successful celebration of the United Nations day of Solidarity with the Palestinian people here in Auckland New Zealand. More than 200 people attended this event.
Berg was so incensed that he had to use one of the most vile accusations one can use against a male. A False Smear of Pedophilia.
Then there is Juliet Moses - Spokesperson for the NZ Jewish Council
Where do, what has now been called, these Propagandists for Israel come from?
Where do, what has now been called, these Propagandists for Israel come from?
So. So far this year I have had to suffer:
- Juliet Moses - Neil Scott is an Incil! (see below)
- Dane Giraud - Neil Scott F#cks his mother! (see below)
- Rob Berg - Neil Scott is a Pedofile!
Early 2020 - Update
I had another run in with Dane Giraud on Twitter early in 2020.
It seems as if Dane Giraud decided to show his real character in what he thinks about me.
I had another run in with Dane Giraud on Twitter early in 2020.
It seems as if Dane Giraud decided to show his real character in what he thinks about me.
In this Disgusting attack, he smears the memory of my Dead Mother.
Then goes on to say he is - "Not Sorry".
Then Bocks me again.
This Visceral hatred of me for just standing up for Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel by Dane Giraud shows that his motivations to write his Litany of Lies about me.
The Pro Israel Apartheid supporters, including Giraud, are Desperate to divert the debate from the zionist Ideology which has at it's Core, Racism, Terrorism, Land Theft and Ethnic Cleansing to False Smears of anti Semitism.
People who stand up for Human Rights can sign a petition calling for the New Zealand government to speak up on the Illagal Occupation of Palestine and the Siege of Gaza here.
Nga mihi
Neil
Then goes on to say he is - "Not Sorry".
Then Bocks me again.
This Visceral hatred of me for just standing up for Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel by Dane Giraud shows that his motivations to write his Litany of Lies about me.
The Pro Israel Apartheid supporters, including Giraud, are Desperate to divert the debate from the zionist Ideology which has at it's Core, Racism, Terrorism, Land Theft and Ethnic Cleansing to False Smears of anti Semitism.
People who stand up for Human Rights can sign a petition calling for the New Zealand government to speak up on the Illagal Occupation of Palestine and the Siege of Gaza here.
Nga mihi
Neil
27/11/2019 - Update
After tweeting that I had posted my short response to Giraud's Litany of Lies here, I received the following reply from (probably) David Cumin of the Israel Institute of New Zealand.
After tweeting that I had posted my short response to Giraud's Litany of Lies here, I received the following reply from (probably) David Cumin of the Israel Institute of New Zealand.
"Thanks for submitting it."?
First, the fact is that I Never submitted this Reply to David Cumin at the IINZ. I posted it here.
David Cumin Never responded to my numerous requests to host my Reply!
So in this matter, David Cumin is simply Lying! Joining Giraud in writing Fantasy Fiction for zionism!
The second thing to consider is that Cumin's tweet says "your "short version" does not meet our minimum editorial standards". . .
As if any Right of Reply has to be agreed to by the Host for content/substance. That is the antithesis of Free Speech and Debate!
David Cumin, "Champion" of the Free Speech Coalition and a supposed supporter of Debate on Palestine/Israel, fails at this first hurdle!
Nga mighi
Neil
First, the fact is that I Never submitted this Reply to David Cumin at the IINZ. I posted it here.
David Cumin Never responded to my numerous requests to host my Reply!
So in this matter, David Cumin is simply Lying! Joining Giraud in writing Fantasy Fiction for zionism!
The second thing to consider is that Cumin's tweet says "your "short version" does not meet our minimum editorial standards". . .
As if any Right of Reply has to be agreed to by the Host for content/substance. That is the antithesis of Free Speech and Debate!
David Cumin, "Champion" of the Free Speech Coalition and a supposed supporter of Debate on Palestine/Israel, fails at this first hurdle!
Nga mighi
Neil
Preamble
Kia ora folks
You may have become aware of the Open Letter (see below) to John Minto from Dane Giraud calling me an anti Semite, a Neo Nazi, etc on the David Cumin supported Israel Institute of New Zealand website.
Please note that I have requested a number of times to have this Right of Reply posted on the IINZ website but David Cumin is has ignored a request for a rely to counter Dane Giraud’s Misrepresentations and Litany of Lies to stand on the IINZ website. So much for the idea of Free Speech that David Cumin claims to be a champion for here in New Zealand.
Because of the complexity of Giraud’s letter, this explanation takes a bit of time. (A shorter version can be found here)
Note. Throughout this Reply, you will see I use zionist in lower case. This is because I hold Political zionism with it’s core of Racism, Terrorism, Land Theft, Ethnic Cleansing and Apartheid in contempt. Just as I do nazi ideology! (no. I am Not saying zionism = nazism before Giraud comes along and Lies about this as well. I just see Both as contemptible based on their Ideologies!)
About Dane Giraud and the Trigger for his Litany of Lies
Dane Giraud is a writer of Fiction for Television and likes to tell Crude jokes on his Twitter time line. Some would call him a practised Potty Mouth who has made jokes about Masturbating with socks and even about his Grandmother having sex with Graeme Henry if she won a dinner date with him.
The back story on this, the Trigger, for Giraud‘s letter is that he and I had a Twitter debate as happens from time to time as I take on our Trio of NZ zionists – David Cumin, Rob Berg and Juliet Moses. (more about these three Political zionists and what they do later)
I said that Benny Morris had documented Ethnic Cleansing in 1948. Giraud said I had Never read Benny Morris. 4 times Giraud repeated this.
So I took screen shots of my Auckland Library history on Morris and tweeted them to Giraud. 12 times in 13 years (Phew), so I asked for Giraud to withdraw his Misrepresentations.
Giraud promptly Blocked me on Twitter. Not Man enough to just admit his mistake, he Cut and Ran. . . Becoming a Proven Liar at the same time. . .
So. Angry and Embarrassed, Giraud did what he does best as a writer of Fiction for Television, he got on with writing more Fiction.
Having read the “Open Letter”, I have identified 20 deliberate Misrepresentations about Myself or John Minto.
The following pages are my response to these Misrepresentations. And having indicated that I would do this, Dane Giraud has become more and more Shrill in repeating his False charges of anti Semitism. You know. The Trick. And neo nazism.
Kia ora folks
You may have become aware of the Open Letter (see below) to John Minto from Dane Giraud calling me an anti Semite, a Neo Nazi, etc on the David Cumin supported Israel Institute of New Zealand website.
Please note that I have requested a number of times to have this Right of Reply posted on the IINZ website but David Cumin is has ignored a request for a rely to counter Dane Giraud’s Misrepresentations and Litany of Lies to stand on the IINZ website. So much for the idea of Free Speech that David Cumin claims to be a champion for here in New Zealand.
Because of the complexity of Giraud’s letter, this explanation takes a bit of time. (A shorter version can be found here)
Note. Throughout this Reply, you will see I use zionist in lower case. This is because I hold Political zionism with it’s core of Racism, Terrorism, Land Theft, Ethnic Cleansing and Apartheid in contempt. Just as I do nazi ideology! (no. I am Not saying zionism = nazism before Giraud comes along and Lies about this as well. I just see Both as contemptible based on their Ideologies!)
About Dane Giraud and the Trigger for his Litany of Lies
Dane Giraud is a writer of Fiction for Television and likes to tell Crude jokes on his Twitter time line. Some would call him a practised Potty Mouth who has made jokes about Masturbating with socks and even about his Grandmother having sex with Graeme Henry if she won a dinner date with him.
The back story on this, the Trigger, for Giraud‘s letter is that he and I had a Twitter debate as happens from time to time as I take on our Trio of NZ zionists – David Cumin, Rob Berg and Juliet Moses. (more about these three Political zionists and what they do later)
I said that Benny Morris had documented Ethnic Cleansing in 1948. Giraud said I had Never read Benny Morris. 4 times Giraud repeated this.
So I took screen shots of my Auckland Library history on Morris and tweeted them to Giraud. 12 times in 13 years (Phew), so I asked for Giraud to withdraw his Misrepresentations.
Giraud promptly Blocked me on Twitter. Not Man enough to just admit his mistake, he Cut and Ran. . . Becoming a Proven Liar at the same time. . .
So. Angry and Embarrassed, Giraud did what he does best as a writer of Fiction for Television, he got on with writing more Fiction.
Having read the “Open Letter”, I have identified 20 deliberate Misrepresentations about Myself or John Minto.
The following pages are my response to these Misrepresentations. And having indicated that I would do this, Dane Giraud has become more and more Shrill in repeating his False charges of anti Semitism. You know. The Trick. And neo nazism.
As noted above, David Cumin who seems to be in control of the Israeli Institute website has ignored my repeated request for a Right of Reply. This has surprised me as Cumin Claims to be a Champion of “Free Speech” in New Zealand and part of the Free Speech Coalition. His actions suggest that he is more like a “Free Speech Fraudster”!
My only conclusion is that the idea of Cumin as a "Free Speech Champion" in New Zealand, as he is wanting to portray himself, has just evaporated in a puff of smoke over refusing to give a Right of reply to Giraud's Misrepresentations.
I pointed out to Giraud that trying to put forward the Fiction that swirls around in his head as truth doesn't work out in the Real World. People want Facts and Truth. But then, Facts and Truth get in the way of a good story. . .
Please Note - I am doing this in My Private Capacity and it has Nothing to do with my involvement as Secretary of the Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa – www.PSNA.nz
More Background for Context
There is a fight for Hearts and Minds going on in New Zealand.
The Core of this fight is on one side, a Racist Racial Privilege for Jews in Palestine and on the other side, Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel.
A Trio of New Zealand Political zionists, aided by a small group of other NZ zionists like Giraud, are desperately attempting to divert peoples attention from the reality of what is happening in the Occupied Palestinain Territories in Palestine:
These are the real reasons our Trio of NZ zionists are active in public.
They want to divert your attention from this list of unconcionable abuses.
Therefore, the tactic that NZ zionists are using to try to shut down debate on these issues is False Charges of anti Semitism against anyone who they see taking an even handed aproach on these issues or show a tendency to support Palestinian Human Rights. They attack MP's, Government departments and Human Rights activists.
Make no bones about this. When you look at this struggle, you will have chose between Israeli State Racism, Terrorism and Ethnic Cleansing to enforce a racist Racial Privilege in Palestine or Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine.
Or as many do, just look the other way. They say that when watching Abuses happening and you do Nothing, You are supporting that Abuse!
The key
Giraud’s suggestion that I am an anti Semite breaks down when people review my activity.
I agree that I criticise the Political Activities of a Trio of NZ zionists who Proudly climbed onto the Political Stage here in New Zealand to try to dominate the media and, it looks like, to cower New Zealand Politicians from taking a stand for Palestinian Human Rights. That Political zionist Trio is David Cumin, Rob Berg and Juliet Moses. More about this Trio later.
Giraud’s position is that Any criticism of the actions and positions taken by any of this Trio of NZ Political zionists is anti Semitic. That any criticism of the Trio is a criticism of the New Zealand Jewish Community as a Whole!
One can see that this position is a Deliberate Misrepresentation. One I call a Deliberate Lie in an attempt to Smear anyone who calls for Palestinian Human Rights. “The Trick” as explained by an ex Israeli Politician. See above.
A position Criticised by the Author of the IHRA Working Definition of anti Semitism in it’s attempt to shut down Legitimate Debate. See here.
Having shown Dane to be a Liar once again, I could stop now.
But, as they say, Wait. There’s More.
I want to outline each of our Trio of NZ Political zionists so you understand why I am criticising each of them specifically. Rather than the NZ Jewish Community as a whole as Giraud Misrepresents!
Rob Berg – President of the zionist Federation of New Zealand
David Cumin – Lead person in the Israel Institute of New Zealand (IINZ)
Juliet Moses – “I am a Zionist!”
My only conclusion is that the idea of Cumin as a "Free Speech Champion" in New Zealand, as he is wanting to portray himself, has just evaporated in a puff of smoke over refusing to give a Right of reply to Giraud's Misrepresentations.
I pointed out to Giraud that trying to put forward the Fiction that swirls around in his head as truth doesn't work out in the Real World. People want Facts and Truth. But then, Facts and Truth get in the way of a good story. . .
Please Note - I am doing this in My Private Capacity and it has Nothing to do with my involvement as Secretary of the Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa – www.PSNA.nz
More Background for Context
There is a fight for Hearts and Minds going on in New Zealand.
The Core of this fight is on one side, a Racist Racial Privilege for Jews in Palestine and on the other side, Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel.
A Trio of New Zealand Political zionists, aided by a small group of other NZ zionists like Giraud, are desperately attempting to divert peoples attention from the reality of what is happening in the Occupied Palestinain Territories in Palestine:
- Deliberate Executions/Murders at the Gaza Concentration Camp fence by Israeli Snipers who can chose which eye to hit to kill someone at 200 meters. More than 50 Children, some as young as 4 years old, 6 Medics helping the wounded, Journalists documenting the events and even a man with No Legs who was taken to the fence in a wheel chair. All Unarmed Civilians and Deliberately Killed by Israel!
- Maiming of Palestinian youths at the Gaza fence by Israeli Snipers using of Illegal Dum Dum bullets. More than 150 maimed through amputations so far!
- Note that 80% of the Palestinains living in Gaza are Refugees from land that is within the state of Israel.
- The ongoing Theft of Palestinian lands and the Ethnic Cleansing of Palestinian areas used to build illegal settlements. A War Crime under International Law
- The Machine Gunning of Palestinian Fishermen
- The refusal to allow medical attention to Palestinains shot by Israeli military forces. Leaving treatable people to bleed to death as the Israeli soldiers watch.
- Refusal to allow all people requiring medical attention out of Gaza to receive it meaning Gazans are pushed back into Gaza to die of treatable diseases
- The Systematic bombing of Civilian Infrastructure in Gaza which is part of Israel's "Dahiya Doctrine" of attacking Civilian infrastructure and Killing Civilians to create a "Deterrent". A prescription for War Crimes.
- The closing of Checkpoints in the West Bank and not allowing women in Childbirth passage to hospitals leading to the deaths of 71 babies in Childbirth. Infanticide by any other name
- The use of High Velocity Tear gas cannisters fired directly at the head to Kill and Maim
- The arrest and abuse of Palestinian children. Refusing them access to Lawyers and then putting them into Stress position to try to elicit confessions. Transfer of many Children from the Occupied Palestinian territories into Israel which is a War Crime under International Law. And reports of Sexual abuse to both Male and Female Palestinian Children.
- The transfer of members of the Israeli Population into the Occupied territories (illegal settlements) which is a war Crime
- Settler violence against Palestinains in the Occupied territories and the destruction of olive trees which is a key income earner
- Then there is Israel being taken to the International Criminal Court for investigation for War Crimes!
- And many, many more attrocities!
These are the real reasons our Trio of NZ zionists are active in public.
They want to divert your attention from this list of unconcionable abuses.
Therefore, the tactic that NZ zionists are using to try to shut down debate on these issues is False Charges of anti Semitism against anyone who they see taking an even handed aproach on these issues or show a tendency to support Palestinian Human Rights. They attack MP's, Government departments and Human Rights activists.
Make no bones about this. When you look at this struggle, you will have chose between Israeli State Racism, Terrorism and Ethnic Cleansing to enforce a racist Racial Privilege in Palestine or Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine.
Or as many do, just look the other way. They say that when watching Abuses happening and you do Nothing, You are supporting that Abuse!
The key
Giraud’s suggestion that I am an anti Semite breaks down when people review my activity.
I agree that I criticise the Political Activities of a Trio of NZ zionists who Proudly climbed onto the Political Stage here in New Zealand to try to dominate the media and, it looks like, to cower New Zealand Politicians from taking a stand for Palestinian Human Rights. That Political zionist Trio is David Cumin, Rob Berg and Juliet Moses. More about this Trio later.
Giraud’s position is that Any criticism of the actions and positions taken by any of this Trio of NZ Political zionists is anti Semitic. That any criticism of the Trio is a criticism of the New Zealand Jewish Community as a Whole!
One can see that this position is a Deliberate Misrepresentation. One I call a Deliberate Lie in an attempt to Smear anyone who calls for Palestinian Human Rights. “The Trick” as explained by an ex Israeli Politician. See above.
A position Criticised by the Author of the IHRA Working Definition of anti Semitism in it’s attempt to shut down Legitimate Debate. See here.
Having shown Dane to be a Liar once again, I could stop now.
But, as they say, Wait. There’s More.
I want to outline each of our Trio of NZ Political zionists so you understand why I am criticising each of them specifically. Rather than the NZ Jewish Community as a whole as Giraud Misrepresents!
Rob Berg – President of the zionist Federation of New Zealand
- Berg is a British man who Volunteered to join the Israel Military to join in the Vicious, Abusive Occupation of the people in the Occupied Palestinian Territories. He wasn't Conscripted but Volunteered!
- Berg could have joined the British army and gone to serve in Afghanistan to fight the Taliban, a well trained and armed militia, but he Chose to join the Israeli Military where he would have Known that he would be able to Abuse, Maim and Kill Unarmed Palestinian Civilians with little or No Consequences. I have no idea of which branch of the Israeli Military Berg was in, Soldier, Artillery, Tanks, Sniper or Intelligence!
- I recently asked Berg if he is still in the Israeli Military. As Israelis are in the Israeli Military Reserves for up to 20 - 30 years this is quite a reasonable question. And relevant to the debate. Some operate Clandestinely overseas assuming covers to hide their activities. . . So far, Berg has avoided answering whether he is still in the Israeli Military or whether he served in any Israeli Intelligence Unit. . .
- Then Berg, for some reason came to New Zealand. I have looked up Berg to see if he has a job here and All I can find is that he is the President of the Zionist Federation of New Zealand. Extremely active on the Political stage attacking anyone who shows even handedness or being possibly pro Palestinian Human Rights. A British man here in New Zealand attacking NZ MP’s like Duncan Webb, Golriz Ghahraman and Marama Davidson.
- Recently, Berg tweeted, about the Rugby World Cup just before the UK/NZ game, Swing Low sweet Chariot. Fair enough. He is British after all.
- Given he lives in NZ, I made a joke about that and about Loyalty. . . More to come below.
David Cumin – Lead person in the Israel Institute of New Zealand (IINZ)
- Cumin is a Lecturer in Anesthesiology and Medical Ethics at the University of Auckland. Remember that - "Ethics". . .
- Cumin seems to be the main person at IINZ. With a twitter account has been Shown to be a Sock Puppet for Tel Aviv as Tweets come out at 10pm, 12pm, 2am, 4am, 6am etc. . . Daytime Tel Aviv. Maybe there is an automated system tweeting as Cumin claims but that doesn’t explain the series of Re-Tweets that come out at similar times. He would have to know they were coming to do that. Magic? Or. . .
- The tweets are all about how great Israel is. And how bad Palestinians are. I am yet to see many/any tweets about how great NZ is. . .
- Cumin is also a Champion for the Free Speech Coalition where he was pushing for the Publication in NZ of the Christchurch Terrorists Manifesto on how to track down and Kill Muslims in New Zealand. Free (Hate) Speech and all that. . . Imagine if there was a similar manifesto about tracking down and Killing Jews here in New Zealand? Of course, like the rest of us, Cumin would be all for banning that manifesto!
- Cumin regularly Falsely charges people as being anti Semites when He disagrees with them. Like New Zealand MP’s who have shown to be open minded on the Palestine/Israeli issue.
- I once met Cumin at a Pro Palestine Rally in Aotea square where we had a chat. Initially, he was reluctant to shake my hand as I held it out to him. (a simple recognition of each other’s Humanity.) Something he is reluctant to do each time I meet him. He took great delight in discussing my Facebook page which he was intimately knowledgeable of almost as if he had been Stalking me. When I said that Israeli had 50 Racist laws on the books, Cumin pointed out that it actually had more than 60, smiling as he corrected me.
- Cumin has turned up to a number of PSNA events like Rallys, talks by speakers, etc. Feedback from Palestinains is that they believe he turns up to Intimidate them. Others inform me that they are scared to turn up at Pro Palestinian Rallys because they fear that, as happened in the South African Aparthied era, their names will be sent back to Israel and their relatives will be Harrassed or, even worse, Killed.
- At the Rally, I asked Cumin three times whether the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Geneva Conventions applies to Palestinians. Each time Cumin avoided answering! I have found out that Cumin Maintains that the Palestinians have No Rights or Protections under Geneva Conventions even though the UN recognises their status as being under occupation. It took Cumin 10 months to agree, after an international tweeter embarrassed him by asked him about this, that yes, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) applied to Palestinians. He couldn’t bring himself to actually write the words and stuck with UDHR
- Recently, Cumin has been involved in the Smear of Kia Ora Gaza saying it hosts Anti Semitic posts. The Kai Ora Gaza Facebook page is an open forum, which Cumin rejects for the IINZ site, so is it possible for anti Semitic posts to be put up. But. . . I Know Roger Fowler and Know he is very quick to take down any anti Semitic posts that are made. This leads me to the conclusion that someone has made an anti Semitic post on the Kia Ora Gaza Facebook page and then quickly taken a screen grab of it, before it was taken down by Roger. To be used in a kind of False attack? It is also noticeable that the attackers of Kia Ora Gaza don’t provide any link to any anti Semitic post indicating that they may Know that they have been deleted. And the images are of a post, not in a thread, which means they could have come from anywhere on the Internet.
- Remembering the John Minto - David Cumin debate, which Cumin Falsely claimed as an IINZ event when it was PSNA who booked the room, organised the microphones and tables (how dishonest does one want to be). One had to be stunned by the Casual Racism of Cumin’s comments. He tried the debunked “A Land without People for a People without Land” in his comment that Palestine was “Sparsely Populated” in 1948. Showing that he doesn’t seem to believe that the 750,000 Palestinians Deliberately Ethnically Cleansed by zionist Terrorist Gangs to create a "Jewish State" somehow were part of the Population. Or that the 565 Palestinian villages depopulated had any relevance! “Sparsely Populated”? Cumin Shames himself with this Deliberate and Practised Racist statement!
- Then there was his assertion that it wasn’t Murder when John Minto said that Civilians were being Murdered at the Gaza fence. Let’s unpick this. Israeli Snipers Are Deliberately Killing Unarmed Civilians at the Gaza fence including more than 50 Children, 6 Medics, 4 Journalists and even a man with No legs who had been taken there in a Wheelchair. A Sniper can hit someone in the head at 800 meters or hit a 1 ½ inch (3.8 cm) circle at 200 meters. So at 200 meters at the Gaza fence, Israeli Snipers are choosing which eye to shoot someone though to Kill them. Or which Bone of the leg, using their Illegal Butterfly Bullets, to cause Horrific wounds and Amputations.
- So for Cumin to say that an Israeli Sniper, knowing Exactly where the Bullet he will fire will land, is Not committing Murder when he/she Kills a little 4 year old child or a Medic bent over a wounded Gazan or a Journalist taking photos seems to show that David Cumin doesn’t believe those people Killed were Murdered. Basically, does Cumin think that it is Not Murder because he doesn’t count Palestinians as Human?
- There is much more but that snippet shows us all who and what Cumin really is.
Juliet Moses – “I am a Zionist!”
- Moses is a senior partner of the Auckland Law Firm TGT Legal
- Moses, as a Lawyer, and with her deep interest in Palestine/Israel, will know International Law in regards to the Belligerent Occupation of Palestinian Lands. Yet I have never seen Moses acknowledge that International Law has any relevance here.
- Moses Pretends to Just be a spokesperson for the NZ Jewish Council but this is inaccurate.
- Moses Deliberately climbed onto the Political stage when she made a video in 2017 declaring “I am a zionist”!
- Moses carried out an attack on the Ministry of Immigration when it showed that Palestinian Refugees came from the land of. . . Palestine. Moses declared that to show a map of Historic Palestine in 1948 was wiping Israel off the map. What is happening is the exact Opposite. Since 1948, zionist Israel has been deliberately Wiping Palestine off the Map!
- Starting with the more than 100 zionist Terrorist Massacres that were used to force the resident Arab Population to flee for their lives. Including Dier Yassin. This Ethnic Cleansing has been carrying on since 1948 with a continuation in 1967 when Israel attacked the surrounding territories in a “Lebensraum” style grab.
- I started asking Moses if she would agree that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the convention of the Rights of the Child and the 4th Geneva Convention applied to Palestinians. Moses blocked me on Twitter. It took Moses 10 long months to agree, just after David Cumin and a month before the Christchurch Massacre, that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights applies to Palestinians. Seemingly, Moses unblocked me, tweeted me her New position and then promptly Blocked me again so I couldn't see her Tweet. Then threatened to sue me when I said she refused to say that she agreed that the UDHR applies to Palestinians. I am yet to see Moses Tweet as she continues to block me. Maybe she did tweet that. Maybe she didn't. But because of her Blocking me, I have never seen that tweet!
- Moses has yet to agree that the Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Geneva Conventions applies to Palestinians. Something that Anyone with a developed Moral Compass would agree with at the first time asked!
- At the time of the Christchurch Massacre, Moses rushed to wrap her arms around the NZ Muslim community. I pointed out that she opposed the Murder of Muslim Civilians in NZ but seemed supportive of the state of Israel as it Murdered hundreds of Muslim Civilians at the Gaza Concentration Camp fence. Moses seemed to be working hard to try to divert people’s attention away from that Slaughter. I remember that at the time, I called it Opportunistic and Hypocritical. That the Killing of 51 Muslims in NZ was Bad. The Killing of Hundreds of Muslim Civilians at the fence at Gaza – Just Look the other way!
- I followed that up with a statement when Palestinian Children are being Killed and Maimed at the Gaza Concentration Camp fence, Moses ignores this Deliberate slaughter and would rather wish people Happy Diwali. As if wishing people Happy Diwali will divert people’s attention from the Horror that Israel is carrying out at the Gaza fence on a weekly basis. Actions recently criticised by the UN!
- It is obvious that Juliet Moses doesn't like me. Her sexual slander confirms it:
Danes Giraud’s Letter (A Litany of Misrepresentations and Lies)
Giraud’s text in black. My response to Giraud’s Misrepresentations/Lies are in Red
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dear John,
I recently watched Dr David Cumin and you debate your respective “Perspectives on Israel”.
At the event you not only dismissed charges of antisemitism against you personally Because John Minto is Not an anti Semite. Silly little twist. It’s like saying “when did you stop beating your wife”. Because when you say you didn’t beat the wife, they will then say “you deny beating your wife”. A trick used by TV sit com writers. John Minto has been fighting Racism for Decades including his actions opposing Apartheid South Africa. Which means it is no surprise that Minto opposes Apartheid Israel! but also the general accusation that antisemitism is the engine of much of the anti-Israel movement Because it just isn’t. A desire for Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine is the drive for us. We oppose anti Semitism when we see it as John Minto outlined in his speech You told the crowd that when people who single out the Jewish state for destruction Misrepresentation # 1 This is simply untrue. John Minto Never said what Giraud is saying here. Giraud uses to common tactic I have noticed Zionists around the world doing of putting words into peoples mouths and then criticising them for things they Never said) and falsely blame Israel for all manner of egregious sins are challenged as modern peddlers of an ancient hatred, this is an orchestrated campaign run by Jews to silence critics of Israel. Well. . . The Author of the IHRA Working Definition of anti Semitism criticises zionists for using False charges of anti Semitism to shut down Genuine debate. See here
Your evidence for this was a single 2003 interview with a disgruntled far-Left Israeli MP, Shulamit Aloni, which you claim brought into the sunlight what you refer to as “The Trick”. Misrepresentation # 2 - Reference the Author of the IHRA again
I wonder if you will be able to dismiss the following Tweets so easily.
I recently tangled Dane Lied on Twitter about my reading Benny Morris. When I proved him to have Lied, he Blocked me on Twitter. That was the “Tangle”) with a colleague of yours on Twitter. Neil Scott – secretary of your new Misrepresentation # 3 - PSNA is a revamped group. NZ PSN has been around since 2013 - 6 years. Holding Rallies at Aotea Square in Auckland for over 20 years! Palestinian Solidarity Network group. I was drawn into the fray Misrepresentation # 4. It was because Giraud Lied about my reading Benny Morris. And I then Proved Giraud to be a Lying by his serial harassment of members of the local Jewish community (Misrepresentation #5 – I criticise a Trio of Political zionists and Not the whole New Zealand Jewish Community as Giraud tries to portrait. Just Cumin, Berg, Moses, and recently, Giraud and Shane Lust. Cumin, Berg and Moses have all Chosen to take political positions in this arena and have been very prominent in Public. Reference Moses “I am a zionist”. Berg is President of the Zionist Federation of NZ and Cumin seems to be the main person behind IINZ. All three are vocal on the NZ Political stage defending Israel’s abuse of the Captive Palestinian population under Occupation! Giraud is saying that they are above criticism because they are Jewish. Not so. That in itself is Racist.), which included the spewing of his customary bile on a thread in which a representative (political NZ zionist - Moses) was wishing the Indian community a happy Diwali. (I pointed out that Moses wishes Indians Happy Diwali as she looks the other way on Israeli Snipers Deliberately Killing Unarmed Civilians at the Gaza fence. More than 50 children, 6 Medics, 4 Journalists and a man with No legs. A cynical ploy to try to get New Zealanders to think that Israel is good as it continues to Maim and Kill. No comment on this at all)
A class act.
Neil Scott’s Tweets (and these are merely a selection) aren’t just far-Right adjacent, John; they are neo-Nazi tropes Misrepresentation # 6 Giraud has Misrepresented the wording of what is said. Not All Jews are zionists. Many (Christian) zionists are Not Jews. I critise zionism with its Racist, Terrorist and Ethnic Cleansing Ideology. that could have been taken, without a word changed, well, Giraud Had to change words so it fitted with his position from the notorious White Supremacist website The Daily Stormer. In fact, I very quickly found the same ideas expressed by Scott (Misrepresentation # 7. I have never posted on the Daily Stormer. Jeez, I don’t even know where it is) on the “Jewish Problem” part of the Daily Stormer site.
Giraud’s text in black. My response to Giraud’s Misrepresentations/Lies are in Red
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dear John,
I recently watched Dr David Cumin and you debate your respective “Perspectives on Israel”.
At the event you not only dismissed charges of antisemitism against you personally Because John Minto is Not an anti Semite. Silly little twist. It’s like saying “when did you stop beating your wife”. Because when you say you didn’t beat the wife, they will then say “you deny beating your wife”. A trick used by TV sit com writers. John Minto has been fighting Racism for Decades including his actions opposing Apartheid South Africa. Which means it is no surprise that Minto opposes Apartheid Israel! but also the general accusation that antisemitism is the engine of much of the anti-Israel movement Because it just isn’t. A desire for Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine is the drive for us. We oppose anti Semitism when we see it as John Minto outlined in his speech You told the crowd that when people who single out the Jewish state for destruction Misrepresentation # 1 This is simply untrue. John Minto Never said what Giraud is saying here. Giraud uses to common tactic I have noticed Zionists around the world doing of putting words into peoples mouths and then criticising them for things they Never said) and falsely blame Israel for all manner of egregious sins are challenged as modern peddlers of an ancient hatred, this is an orchestrated campaign run by Jews to silence critics of Israel. Well. . . The Author of the IHRA Working Definition of anti Semitism criticises zionists for using False charges of anti Semitism to shut down Genuine debate. See here
Your evidence for this was a single 2003 interview with a disgruntled far-Left Israeli MP, Shulamit Aloni, which you claim brought into the sunlight what you refer to as “The Trick”. Misrepresentation # 2 - Reference the Author of the IHRA again
I wonder if you will be able to dismiss the following Tweets so easily.
I recently tangled Dane Lied on Twitter about my reading Benny Morris. When I proved him to have Lied, he Blocked me on Twitter. That was the “Tangle”) with a colleague of yours on Twitter. Neil Scott – secretary of your new Misrepresentation # 3 - PSNA is a revamped group. NZ PSN has been around since 2013 - 6 years. Holding Rallies at Aotea Square in Auckland for over 20 years! Palestinian Solidarity Network group. I was drawn into the fray Misrepresentation # 4. It was because Giraud Lied about my reading Benny Morris. And I then Proved Giraud to be a Lying by his serial harassment of members of the local Jewish community (Misrepresentation #5 – I criticise a Trio of Political zionists and Not the whole New Zealand Jewish Community as Giraud tries to portrait. Just Cumin, Berg, Moses, and recently, Giraud and Shane Lust. Cumin, Berg and Moses have all Chosen to take political positions in this arena and have been very prominent in Public. Reference Moses “I am a zionist”. Berg is President of the Zionist Federation of NZ and Cumin seems to be the main person behind IINZ. All three are vocal on the NZ Political stage defending Israel’s abuse of the Captive Palestinian population under Occupation! Giraud is saying that they are above criticism because they are Jewish. Not so. That in itself is Racist.), which included the spewing of his customary bile on a thread in which a representative (political NZ zionist - Moses) was wishing the Indian community a happy Diwali. (I pointed out that Moses wishes Indians Happy Diwali as she looks the other way on Israeli Snipers Deliberately Killing Unarmed Civilians at the Gaza fence. More than 50 children, 6 Medics, 4 Journalists and a man with No legs. A cynical ploy to try to get New Zealanders to think that Israel is good as it continues to Maim and Kill. No comment on this at all)
A class act.
Neil Scott’s Tweets (and these are merely a selection) aren’t just far-Right adjacent, John; they are neo-Nazi tropes Misrepresentation # 6 Giraud has Misrepresented the wording of what is said. Not All Jews are zionists. Many (Christian) zionists are Not Jews. I critise zionism with its Racist, Terrorist and Ethnic Cleansing Ideology. that could have been taken, without a word changed, well, Giraud Had to change words so it fitted with his position from the notorious White Supremacist website The Daily Stormer. In fact, I very quickly found the same ideas expressed by Scott (Misrepresentation # 7. I have never posted on the Daily Stormer. Jeez, I don’t even know where it is) on the “Jewish Problem” part of the Daily Stormer site.
Colonel Testifying Against Trump in Hoax Impeachment Fiasco is a Jewish Refugee from the Ukraine
“Make no mistake about it, Jews are loyal to their race first and foremost. They are not loyal to whatever country they happen to reside in and that includes the United States” |
Both Neil Scott and the Daily Stormer repeat an old trope that Jews aren’t loyal to countries they live in.
Misrepresentation # 8 When you read the tweet, you will see that I Specifically spoke about Rob Berg as an INDIVIDUAL. The previous tweet was about Rob Berg backing England in the Rugby World Cup and I replied to it. About Berg. A British man who didn’t join the British army but the Israeli Army. Does Berg still have any ties to the Israeli Military? Considering Berg’s activities in Israel and Bergs activities here in New Zealand, which country do people think that Berg as an individual would be more Loyal to? New Zealand or Israel? And yes. Why did Rob Berg come to NZ? So. I did Not speak about Jews per se. Indeed, we call for the NZ Jewish Community to reject Political zionism for the Racist, Terrorist, Ethnic Cleansing Ideology that it is and take back their Jewish culture. |
Jews are Bankrolling the Subversion of British Politics
“It is a stunning illustration of Jewish power that they have been able to disrupt and subvert Labour as completely as they have, over such a prolonged period, while suffering little or no public criticism of their conduct. Even those having their lives or careers destroyed by Jewish Power dare not call it out or challenge it overtly.” |
On more than one occasion, Neil Scott has claimed that the New Zealand National Party MPs are the hapless puppets of Jewish ("Jewish" was struck through) Zionist masters. This is no different to the Daily Stormer writing about how Jews control politics in Britain.
Misrepresentation # 9. Note how Giraud strikes through the word “Jewish” and inserts Zionist as if trying to imply that All Jews are Zionists! The quote from Paula Bennet Kow Towing to China is readable at the bottom. "Every Praise we give to China is from the heart"! At the last election, National received $3.6 million in Secretive Donations. $250k has been identified as coming from China. The other $3.35 Million came from where? This is a reasonable question given National have shown that they are happy to take funds from overseas. And if they received it from overseas, what did they promise to get it? There was a Parliamentary Friends of Israel group prior to 2017 that was rolled into a Regional group, the Middle East and Africa Group, in early 2018. Later in 2018, the Friends of Israel group reappeared. It is Not a formal Parliamentary Friendship group now. All of the members of this group that I have seen are members of the National Party. . . Which brings up the question, why did National reinvent the Friends of Israel group when Parliament had rolled it into the Regional group? Is this Political payback for something? What other international countries, besides China, are secretly giving funds to the National Party and it’s Members of Parliament? Politics again! Misrepresetnation # 10 Giraud goes on to say that "The NZ National Party MP's" implying I am saying All National Party MP's back Israel. Not so. I do say that there are a number of National Party MP's who are leaning strongly towards Israeli positions and reject discussing Palestinian Human Rights. Something which is slowly changing given Israels actions recently. On Chris Bishop. I have been asking “The Bish” as he once called himself, and other members of the old Friends of Israel group, whether they agree that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR), the Convention on the Rights of the Child and the Geneva Conventions apply to Palestinians. Since approximately March 2017, The Bish has refused to answer and only once giving a sarcastic reply. The Bish is recognised as a supporter of zionist Israel so the conclusion I draw is that he doesn’t want to step on the toes of Cumin, Berg and Moses. Do they have some kind of influence over his agreeing or disagreeing on the UDHR? Decent politicians when asked have No Hestation in agreeing that the UDHR applies to Palestinains. Last on Israeli influence on politics in other countries. Giraud would like you to be unaware of the series The Lobby by Al Jazeera. The Lobby UK covers activities by Israeli agents working out of the Israeli Embassy in London. The actual video can be seen here. Note particularly that they have subverted UK Politicians to act on their behalf and this is caught on Camera. Then there is The Lobby USA where a similar story plays out. You can watch the actual video here. Then there is the American Israel Public Affairs Committee. "Its critics have stated it acts as an agent of the Israeli government with a "stranglehold" on the United States Congress with its power and influence." Indeed, In 1992, AIPAC president David Steiner was forced to resign after he was recorded boasting about his political influence in obtaining aid for Israel". For Giraud to imply that Israel does not activelty work to recruit Politicians around the world to it's cause is plainly Misrepreseantation # 11 |
Jewish Involved in 911
“Yes, it is obvious that the Jews wanted this to happen so that they could kick-start their wars. The neocon Jews wrote about the need for a “Pearl Harbor like event” in their 2000 document entitled “Rebuilding America’s Defenses.” |
Neil Scott has blamed Jews ("Jews" was struck through - note comment above) Zionists for 9/11, just like the far-Right also blame Jews for the worst terror attack on US soil.
Misrepresentation # 12 I point out a fact that a number of men identified as Israelis were dancing in seeming celebration as the Towers were hit. Then the fact about about 3 men who said they were sent to Document the event. 253 Million hits on Google. These are in response to Cumin of the IINZ's comment "but Palestinians celebrated on 9/11" which led to my comment - "Not sure if Dr David Cumin here is telling the Whole truth. ;-)". Based on Girauds position above , David Cumin of the IINZ is blaming the Palestinians for 9/11. On "The Van". This is an interesting part of the thread. There are a large number of people who are interested in finding out the truth about what happened on 9/11. People like the Architects and Engineers for 9/11 truth who Know that what we have been told about what happened on that day to be inaccurate. Here is what they have to say about "The Van" which is linked into the Dancing Israelis. |
One Year After Tree of Life Synagogue Shooting, Goyim Still Face Significant Threat from Jews
“As always, the Jews are accusing the people they are victimizing of doing what they are doing to them. What we see here is just another example of it.” |
Neil Scott has suggested Jews ("Jews" was struck through - note comment above) Zionists were partly responsible for the Christchurch terror attacks, just as the Daily Stormer cites Jews as a danger to non-Jews in the USA and accuses them of trying to pull the U.S. and others into conflicts abroad through false flag operations.
No Thread here. . . Misrepresentation 13 The Terrorism I mention in paragraph 4 is the Terrorism of Israeli Snipers Deliberately Maiming Killing Palestinian Children, Medics and Journalists at the Gaza Concentration Camp fence. (2nd Paragraph) Giraud has tried to Falsely link it to Christchurch. On Paragraph 1, David Cumin himself boasts in a background that he is linked into the NZ Police and NZ SIS. . . One can also note that NZ zionists were demanding at the time for Police action on the desecration of gravestones which is fair. But we also have to note that the NZ SIS were very active in trying to get Muslims to spy on other Muslims in Mosques. Spending considerable resources which could have been better used in finding the Real Terrorist that was walking amongst us. The issue is of Prioritisation and what gets done. I believe that we can All agree that the Police and SIS got it wrong for some reason. |
Neil Scott is the secretary of the supposedly well-intentioned anti-Israel group that you chair. Misrepresentation # 14 PSNA is a Pro Human Rights Organisation pushing for Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel. Giraud sees Pro Human Rights as anti Israel Yet here he is expressing views indiscernible from those presented on the world’s most infamous White Supremacist website. Giraud’s case is been debunked when you ignore his Misrepresentations and read what I actually tweeted. Giraud’s Misrepresentations are a Litany of Lies similar to those I originally called him out on in regards to my reading history of Benny Morris! Once a Liar. . .
Dane has done what Political zionists around the world do on a daily basis. Put words into someones mouth and then criticising them for what they never said. Just too obvious for anyone reading with open eyes and an open mind!
John, do you in any way endorse the views expressed by your group’s secretary, Neil Scott? John and I have discussed this letter and John has replied to Cumin who emailed him on this.
I’ve heard it opined that the political spectrum is not a straight line but more of a horseshoe or even a circle where the fringes – if you travel far enough – will eventually meet. Surely this is the case with Scott, who breaks with the Left and sits unequivocally on the racist Hard-Right when it comes to Jews. Misrepresentation # 15 I oppose Political zionism as an idology with Racism, Terrorism and Ethnic Cleansing at it's Core. Not Judaism or Jews. But you also freely promote the far-Right idea that antisemitism is cynically used by Jews, at every level, to distract from Jewish crimes. as was stated by Aloni (above) and then detailed in the IHRA Working Definition of anti Semitism by the Author You have justified the murder of Israelis and denied Palestinian terrorism Misrepresentation/Lie # 16 Not that I know of. Under International Law, the Occupied have the right to fight occupation. Reference the Warsaw ghetto in WW2, and openly present as the goal of your activism the end of Jewish self-determination Misrepresentation # 17 We are looking for Democracy in Palestine/Israel. Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel. The very words “Jewish self-determination” and “Jewish power” when they mean one group Forcefully Ruling over another Racial group is Racism. The ending of a Vicious Brutal Apartheid Regime will free up Both Jews and Palestinians to live in peace. Giraud’s position seems to be that Apartheid is just fine if it is run in Palestine/Israel by zionists. The end of Jewish power. The end of our ultimate means of self-defense, Misrepresentation # 18 The ending of the Killing of Unarmed Palestinian Civilians, Israeli State Terrorism, is a good thing. Killing unarmed civilians in Cold Blood is Not self Defence. It is Murder and Terrorism! which you frequently present as a rare evil.
What Scott’s Tweets, and more than a few moments in your performance vs. Dr Cumin have taught me is that trying to define far-Right off far-Left antisemitism is a mug’s game. The othering of Jews Misrepresentation # 19 Criticism of a Trio of NZ Political zionists is Not the “Othering of Jews” and the perpetuation of conspiracy theories about what is still a beleaguered minority in most parts of the world Jews are Not a minority in Palestine/Israel. Jews make up approximately 50% of the people there. The Majority of Palestinians have been Concentrated into diminishing areas of land as their land as been taken from them. Indeed, 80% of the 2 Million Palestinians living in Gaza are Refugees from the land that is now Israel. Refugees that had Israeli Citizenship conferred on them by Israeli courts on the day of the declaration of the state of Israel otherwise Israel would have been a country without Citizens. It took Two years for zionists to pass laws which stripped those Palestinain Israeli Refugees of their Israeli Citizenship. is a total and complete departure from the humanist foundations of the Left. Israel has the fifth largest army in the world including more than 200 Nuclear weapons. Israel refuses to apply the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Convention on the Rights of the Child and Geneva Convention to Palestinians. Indeed, We are calling for the New Zealand Jewish Community to return to it’s roots of Tikun Olam and Reject the Racism, Terrorism, Land Theft, Ethnic Cleansing and Apartheid of zionism As far as I’m concerned you have a mountain of work to do to convince me you don’t have a neo-Nazi lieutenant in Neil Scott Having deliberately taken this position of Misrepresentations and a Proven Litany of Lies, Giraud is playing a political game here with his attack and there is little anyone could do to convince him of anything. I reiterate, when I proved him to be wrong about my Reading record of Benny Morris, Giraud blocked me on Twitter in Anger and Embarrassment. Giraud wasn’t man/honest enough to admit that he was wrong then. Even when it was Proven obviously so. It is unlikely that he would admit his Misrepresentations/Lies here!. The real question is, how much of this thought do you, and the wider movement, share? The real questions are:
And if you go to 4 minutes into The Lobby USA, you find out why Giraud has come out to Falsely Smear me, John Minto, 3 NZ MP's, The Ministry of Immigration and the Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa.
Sincerely, Really. . . Giraud is a Practised writer of Fiction afterall. . . Misrepresentation # 20.
Dane Giraud
Dane is a comedy writer (a writer of Fiction. . . for Television. . . where Facts get in the way of a good story. . .) (creator of Find Me A Maori Bride), and a member of the NZ Jewish community.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Dane has done what Political zionists around the world do on a daily basis. Put words into someones mouth and then criticising them for what they never said. Just too obvious for anyone reading with open eyes and an open mind!
John, do you in any way endorse the views expressed by your group’s secretary, Neil Scott? John and I have discussed this letter and John has replied to Cumin who emailed him on this.
I’ve heard it opined that the political spectrum is not a straight line but more of a horseshoe or even a circle where the fringes – if you travel far enough – will eventually meet. Surely this is the case with Scott, who breaks with the Left and sits unequivocally on the racist Hard-Right when it comes to Jews. Misrepresentation # 15 I oppose Political zionism as an idology with Racism, Terrorism and Ethnic Cleansing at it's Core. Not Judaism or Jews. But you also freely promote the far-Right idea that antisemitism is cynically used by Jews, at every level, to distract from Jewish crimes. as was stated by Aloni (above) and then detailed in the IHRA Working Definition of anti Semitism by the Author You have justified the murder of Israelis and denied Palestinian terrorism Misrepresentation/Lie # 16 Not that I know of. Under International Law, the Occupied have the right to fight occupation. Reference the Warsaw ghetto in WW2, and openly present as the goal of your activism the end of Jewish self-determination Misrepresentation # 17 We are looking for Democracy in Palestine/Israel. Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel. The very words “Jewish self-determination” and “Jewish power” when they mean one group Forcefully Ruling over another Racial group is Racism. The ending of a Vicious Brutal Apartheid Regime will free up Both Jews and Palestinians to live in peace. Giraud’s position seems to be that Apartheid is just fine if it is run in Palestine/Israel by zionists. The end of Jewish power. The end of our ultimate means of self-defense, Misrepresentation # 18 The ending of the Killing of Unarmed Palestinian Civilians, Israeli State Terrorism, is a good thing. Killing unarmed civilians in Cold Blood is Not self Defence. It is Murder and Terrorism! which you frequently present as a rare evil.
What Scott’s Tweets, and more than a few moments in your performance vs. Dr Cumin have taught me is that trying to define far-Right off far-Left antisemitism is a mug’s game. The othering of Jews Misrepresentation # 19 Criticism of a Trio of NZ Political zionists is Not the “Othering of Jews” and the perpetuation of conspiracy theories about what is still a beleaguered minority in most parts of the world Jews are Not a minority in Palestine/Israel. Jews make up approximately 50% of the people there. The Majority of Palestinians have been Concentrated into diminishing areas of land as their land as been taken from them. Indeed, 80% of the 2 Million Palestinians living in Gaza are Refugees from the land that is now Israel. Refugees that had Israeli Citizenship conferred on them by Israeli courts on the day of the declaration of the state of Israel otherwise Israel would have been a country without Citizens. It took Two years for zionists to pass laws which stripped those Palestinain Israeli Refugees of their Israeli Citizenship. is a total and complete departure from the humanist foundations of the Left. Israel has the fifth largest army in the world including more than 200 Nuclear weapons. Israel refuses to apply the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, the Convention on the Rights of the Child and Geneva Convention to Palestinians. Indeed, We are calling for the New Zealand Jewish Community to return to it’s roots of Tikun Olam and Reject the Racism, Terrorism, Land Theft, Ethnic Cleansing and Apartheid of zionism As far as I’m concerned you have a mountain of work to do to convince me you don’t have a neo-Nazi lieutenant in Neil Scott Having deliberately taken this position of Misrepresentations and a Proven Litany of Lies, Giraud is playing a political game here with his attack and there is little anyone could do to convince him of anything. I reiterate, when I proved him to be wrong about my Reading record of Benny Morris, Giraud blocked me on Twitter in Anger and Embarrassment. Giraud wasn’t man/honest enough to admit that he was wrong then. Even when it was Proven obviously so. It is unlikely that he would admit his Misrepresentations/Lies here!. The real question is, how much of this thought do you, and the wider movement, share? The real questions are:
- Why is Giraud carrying out this attack with it’s Litany of Misrepresentations and Lies?
- Why is Giraud working to try to protect the Terrorist and Ethnic Cleansing actions of the state of Israel?
- Why is Giraud working to try to defend/protect the work being carried out by a Trio of New Zealand Political zionists?
And if you go to 4 minutes into The Lobby USA, you find out why Giraud has come out to Falsely Smear me, John Minto, 3 NZ MP's, The Ministry of Immigration and the Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa.
Sincerely, Really. . . Giraud is a Practised writer of Fiction afterall. . . Misrepresentation # 20.
Dane Giraud
Dane is a comedy writer (a writer of Fiction. . . for Television. . . where Facts get in the way of a good story. . .) (creator of Find Me A Maori Bride), and a member of the NZ Jewish community.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
And to Wrap Up
I don’t suspect that I will convince anyone who is firmly in the zionist camp with one eye closed.
Indeed, many of our New Zealand Jewish Community won’t get to read this Reply to Giraud’s Litany of Lies because David Cumin is Not Man/Honest enough to post it up on the IINZ website in response to Giraud’s Open Letter.
I do know that growing numbers of people in our New Zealand Jewish Community are appalled by what Israel is doing in the Occupied Palestinian Territories! But they may feel reluctant to speak up based on possible retribution. Like the threats I was told about to the business of Justine Sachs mother when Justine wrote her open letter asking Lorde Not to play in Israel. This is the level of Desperation some people will sink to in their support of political zionism!
The recent decision by the International Criminal Court to take Israel to court for War Crimes has further influenced the thinking of our New Zealand Jewish Community.
But there are more and more Decent Jews around the world standing up to reject the Racism, Ethnic Cleansing, Terrorism and Apartheid of zionism and stand up for Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel.
A short list of those individuals and Organisations:
Peace Groups:
Breaking the Silence www.breakingthesilence.org.il
B’Tselem (in the image of God) www.btselem.org/
Association for Civil Rights in Israel https://www.acri.org.il/en/
Peace Now http://peacenow.org.il/en/
Yachad http://yachad.org.uk/
Gisha http://www.gisha.org/
Hadash http://hadash.org.il/english/
Gush Shalom http://zope.gush-shalom.org/index_en.html
Jews for Justice in Palestine - mesarvot http://jfjfp.com/?tag=mesarvot
Zochrot http://www.zochrot.org/
MachsomWatch https://machsomwatch.org/en/content/home-page
Seeds of Peace https://www.seedsofpeace.org/
Jews And Arabs Refuse To Be Enemies https://web.facebook.com/JewsAndArabsRefuseToBeEnemies
American Jews for a Just Peace https://web.facebook.com/American-Jews-For-A-Just-Peace-29377854397
Count The Kids http://www.countthekids.org/
Independent Jewish Voices https://ijv.org.uk/
YaLa http://yalaacademy.org/
The Jewish Liberation Theology Institute www.JeLiThIn.Ca
The Other Voice http://www.othervoice.org/welcome-eng.htm
Al Haq http://www.alhaq.org/
Jewish Voice for Peace https://jewishvoiceforpeace.org/
Meretz (Political Party) https://meretz.org.il/en/english/
Neturei Karta http://www.nkusa.org/
New Israel Fund https://www.nif.org/
Women Wage Peace http://womenwagepeace.org.il/en/
We Are Not Numbers https://wearenotnumbers.org/home
Hebron Freedom Fund https://www.hebronfreedomfund.org/
Boycott from Within https://boycottisrael.info/
Committee Against Administrative Detention
If Not Now https://ifnotnowmovement.org/
You Never Told Me https://younevertoldme.org/
People/Historians:
- Miko Peled https://mikopeled.com/
- Gideon Levy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gideon_Levy
- Ilan Pappe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilan_Papp%C3%A9
- Richard Silverstein https://www.richardsilverstein.com/
- Israel Shahak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_Shahak
- Anna Baltzer http://www.annainthemiddleeast.com/
- Max Blumenthal http://maxblumenthal.com/
- Mearsheimer and Walt https://www.amazon.com/Israel-Lobby-U-S-Foreign-Policy/dp/0374531501
- Noam Chomsky https://chomsky.info/
- John Pilger http://johnpilger.com/
- Mariam Barghouti https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmuvTvl1n9E
- Amira Hass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amira_Hass
- Ramzy Baroud http://www.ramzybaroud.net/
- Professor Nurit Peled-Elhanan https://www.amazon.com/Palestine-Israeli-School-Books-Propaganda/dp/1845118138
- Benny Morris https://www.amazon.com/Righteous-Victims-Zionist-Arab-Conflict-1881-2001/dp/0679744754
BDS
- Boycott from Within https://boycottisrael.info/
There are other references you can research in other pages on this website.
Individuals and Organisations that Giraud would like to call Anti Semitic but has problems because most of them are Jewish!
But I suspect that anyone reading this with Both eyes open and looking for the truth in my tweets will come to a similar opinion as I have.
Dane Giraud, in a fit of Anger and Embarrassment after having been Proven to be Lying on Twitter has exercised his Fiction writing skills by writing a Litany of Lies in an Open Letter!
Once again, this is the reality of what is happening in Palestine as our Trio of NZ zionists try to convince you that Palestinians are trying to "Wipe Israel off the Map"!
I don’t suspect that I will convince anyone who is firmly in the zionist camp with one eye closed.
Indeed, many of our New Zealand Jewish Community won’t get to read this Reply to Giraud’s Litany of Lies because David Cumin is Not Man/Honest enough to post it up on the IINZ website in response to Giraud’s Open Letter.
I do know that growing numbers of people in our New Zealand Jewish Community are appalled by what Israel is doing in the Occupied Palestinian Territories! But they may feel reluctant to speak up based on possible retribution. Like the threats I was told about to the business of Justine Sachs mother when Justine wrote her open letter asking Lorde Not to play in Israel. This is the level of Desperation some people will sink to in their support of political zionism!
The recent decision by the International Criminal Court to take Israel to court for War Crimes has further influenced the thinking of our New Zealand Jewish Community.
But there are more and more Decent Jews around the world standing up to reject the Racism, Ethnic Cleansing, Terrorism and Apartheid of zionism and stand up for Equal Human Rights for All in Palestine/Israel.
A short list of those individuals and Organisations:
Peace Groups:
Breaking the Silence www.breakingthesilence.org.il
B’Tselem (in the image of God) www.btselem.org/
Association for Civil Rights in Israel https://www.acri.org.il/en/
Peace Now http://peacenow.org.il/en/
Yachad http://yachad.org.uk/
Gisha http://www.gisha.org/
Hadash http://hadash.org.il/english/
Gush Shalom http://zope.gush-shalom.org/index_en.html
Jews for Justice in Palestine - mesarvot http://jfjfp.com/?tag=mesarvot
Zochrot http://www.zochrot.org/
MachsomWatch https://machsomwatch.org/en/content/home-page
Seeds of Peace https://www.seedsofpeace.org/
Jews And Arabs Refuse To Be Enemies https://web.facebook.com/JewsAndArabsRefuseToBeEnemies
American Jews for a Just Peace https://web.facebook.com/American-Jews-For-A-Just-Peace-29377854397
Count The Kids http://www.countthekids.org/
Independent Jewish Voices https://ijv.org.uk/
YaLa http://yalaacademy.org/
The Jewish Liberation Theology Institute www.JeLiThIn.Ca
The Other Voice http://www.othervoice.org/welcome-eng.htm
Al Haq http://www.alhaq.org/
Jewish Voice for Peace https://jewishvoiceforpeace.org/
Meretz (Political Party) https://meretz.org.il/en/english/
Neturei Karta http://www.nkusa.org/
New Israel Fund https://www.nif.org/
Women Wage Peace http://womenwagepeace.org.il/en/
We Are Not Numbers https://wearenotnumbers.org/home
Hebron Freedom Fund https://www.hebronfreedomfund.org/
Boycott from Within https://boycottisrael.info/
Committee Against Administrative Detention
If Not Now https://ifnotnowmovement.org/
You Never Told Me https://younevertoldme.org/
People/Historians:
- Miko Peled https://mikopeled.com/
- Gideon Levy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gideon_Levy
- Ilan Pappe https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ilan_Papp%C3%A9
- Richard Silverstein https://www.richardsilverstein.com/
- Israel Shahak https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Israel_Shahak
- Anna Baltzer http://www.annainthemiddleeast.com/
- Max Blumenthal http://maxblumenthal.com/
- Mearsheimer and Walt https://www.amazon.com/Israel-Lobby-U-S-Foreign-Policy/dp/0374531501
- Noam Chomsky https://chomsky.info/
- John Pilger http://johnpilger.com/
- Mariam Barghouti https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hmuvTvl1n9E
- Amira Hass https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amira_Hass
- Ramzy Baroud http://www.ramzybaroud.net/
- Professor Nurit Peled-Elhanan https://www.amazon.com/Palestine-Israeli-School-Books-Propaganda/dp/1845118138
- Benny Morris https://www.amazon.com/Righteous-Victims-Zionist-Arab-Conflict-1881-2001/dp/0679744754
BDS
- Boycott from Within https://boycottisrael.info/
There are other references you can research in other pages on this website.
Individuals and Organisations that Giraud would like to call Anti Semitic but has problems because most of them are Jewish!
But I suspect that anyone reading this with Both eyes open and looking for the truth in my tweets will come to a similar opinion as I have.
Dane Giraud, in a fit of Anger and Embarrassment after having been Proven to be Lying on Twitter has exercised his Fiction writing skills by writing a Litany of Lies in an Open Letter!
Once again, this is the reality of what is happening in Palestine as our Trio of NZ zionists try to convince you that Palestinians are trying to "Wipe Israel off the Map"!
And here is the Apartheid map that President Trump presented, on Israels behalf, during 2020
Nga mihi
Neil
Neil Scott
Neil
Neil Scott